Leicestershire's Tom Scriven was caught off a bouncer at short mid-off during the One Day Cup semifinal against Somerset, but the square leg umpire deemed it a no-ball for height, sparking discontent among some fans, despite the decision being within the laws of the game.
Cricket has several long-standing rules that continue to divide opinions, and one such rule came into play during the Somerset vs. Leicestershire semifinal on Sunday (August 18). Somerset posted a formidable total of 334 runs, driven by Lewis Goldsworthy’s unbeaten 115 off 86 balls. In response, Leicestershire found themselves in trouble at 106/4 before a 131-run partnership for the fifth wicket revived their hopes. Peter Handscomb led the fightback with a brilliant 111 off 86 deliveries, but ultimately, Leicestershire fell short by 23 runs.
The incident in question occurred during Leicestershire’s run chase. Batting at number 9, Tom Scriven faced Ben Green in the 47th over. Green, after conceding four runs off his first five deliveries, bowled a high bouncer on the last ball, which Scriven attempted to counter by advancing down the pitch. Scriven was caught at short third man, seemingly outwitted by the well-directed bouncer. However, the square leg umpire ruled it a no-ball for being above head height and out of the batter’s reach, giving Scriven a reprieve.
Despite the call being entirely consistent with the laws of the game and the One Day Cup’s playing conditions, a section of fans expressed frustration, feeling the decision was harsh. Such incidents highlight how certain cricket rules, even when correctly applied, can continue to stir debate and polarise opinions among fans.